Monday, 09. December 2013
05. 10. 12. - 14:00
Here in Austria there are many discussions about problems in the health system and about potential new health reforms.
Many of these discussions tend to wield criticism about proposed changes, but according to experts at the European Health Forum Gastein congress currently being held in Austria these changes can be a positive thing and present a 'Window of Change'
Economic crises and recessions affect health systems in entirely different ways. In less-developed countries they represent a severe threat to any progress that has been achieved. But in industrialised societies they can prove to be a motor for breaking up old, out-dated, structures and be the catalyst for renewal, experts told the European Health Forum Gastein. But they argued that sustainable reforms depended on their shape and direction being worked out in advance.
Economic crises can provide an entirely positive impetus to health systems – at least in developed countries. "A health care system stabilises the economy in times of crisis, provided it has adequate reserves and potential for efficiency," Dr Thomas Czypionka, of the Vienna Institute for Advanced Studies, told the European Health Forum Gastein (EHFG). "Conversely, pressure to cut costs in times of recession can actually create opportunities to accelerate reforms in the health sector."
In the main, health care and equality of health treatment in industrialised countries were relatively little affected by crises, he said. Demand for health services did not depend on the economy, indeed the health system as an economic factor (which) could even (things) help out in turbulent times. The OECD had demonstrated this in a 2010 working paper: "In countries where GDP falls, the share of GDP spent on health tends to rise," Dr Czypionka, an expert in health economics and health policy, told the EHFG.
The pressure to cut costs which economic crises bring in their train can also bring about thoroughly positive changes, Dr. Czypionka stressed. "In many developed countries there are traditional structures in need of deeper reforms which are in turn blocked by political resistance. Crises can – though this will not necessarily be the case – be motors for such change, because for a short time they create a wide divergence between need and available finance. This can mean that change has to be implemented which might otherwise not happen till years later."
Dr. Czypionka therefore sees crises as a "windows of opportunity", but ones which quickly close again if there is an improvement in the economic situation. "The pressure is reduced, and more radical changes use up a relatively large amount of political capital." This phenomenon could only be exploited if, before the crisis set in, serious ideas for reform had been developed which, if necessary, could implemented fairly rapidly.
But Dr Czypionka said he saw the current economic crisis in Europe as different in a number of ways: "Its effects are likely to be more sustained than those of previous crises, since not only banks, but in EU countries the whole community has been caught up in the maelstrom. It's hard to quantify such effects, however." The way these worked out in practice had until now been very diverse, according to the WHO's Health Evidence Network: in part, countries had been able to draw on reserves and so expand access to services for the low-paid, or to make their system more efficient.
But many other European countries had been much less well-prepared, reacting by simply making cuts, even abandoning reforms which had already been put in train, or increasing the burden on individuals for using basic services, either by imposing extra costs or lengthening waiting-lists. „I fear that the consequences will be felt for many years to come – possibly most when the demographic trend hits hardest, with all the strains that will impose on health and social systems," Dr Czypionka said.
However, this assessment did not apply to the entire global situation. „In less-developed countries, crises are typically much more damaging than in industrialized countries. Where health systems are still at the development stage, there is very clear evidence of improved quality of life and more equality. Both of these declined in a very immediate way when there are crises, the successes and achievements of reforms going into reverse or even being completely wrecked," said Dr Czypionka.
Current figures have been provided by a research team headed by Christopher JL Murray in the journal Health Affairs. These show there has been a marked slowing-down in the increase in development aid for health projects since 2009. On top of a fall in contributions by donor countries, funding commitments by many UN agencies as well as the Global Fund to Fight AIDS, tuberculosis, and malaria, had stagnated. That there was nonetheless a year-on-year increase of about four per cent was primarily because the World Bank appeared to have deliberately increased its contributions as a reaction to the global economic crisis.
Where crises result in sudden cuts in public health-care spending, this can, according to the WHO's analysis, endanger the health-care of the population at large. What made this worse, said Dr Czypionka, was that forced cuts – best avoided at the best of times – came just when a society needed more, not less, resources to deal with health issues resulting from, for instance, unemployment. There was a risk of destabilization, notably where cuts damaged the financial base of the most important services.
The EHFG is the most important conference on health care policy in the European Union. In this its 15th year, the EHFG attracts more than 600 decision-makers from 45 countries to discuss major topics on the future of the European health care system from 3 to 6 October 2012.
Media Insider: Does Somebody Actually get Paid to Write UNIS Releases?
More proof if proof was needed of how incredibly pointless the United Nations Information Service (UNIS) in Vienna really is.
Austrias SPO disappointed over financial tax
The failure to implement a European tax on financial transactions for next year is disappointing, according to Austrian Chancellor and SPO party leader Werner Faymann.
Ex Wife Loses battle to Claw Back Fortune
The ex-wife of Austrian gun maker Gaston Glock has lost a battle to claim a share of her husband's company, Austria’s highest court (OGH) has ruled.
Final chance to see Elisabeth musical in Vienna
It's the last chance for musical fans to catch the renowned Austrian musical about the story of 19th century Empress Sisi as it enters the final few months of performances in Vienna.
Austrian woman caught drug smuggling in Indonesia
An Austrian woman risks being sentenced to death in Indonesia after she was arrested in late November for attempting to smuggle drugs into the country.
World Record Breaking Ski World Record Attempt
The Austrian capital already holds many records, often voted the city with the best quality of life in the world, or being the only capital city with vineyards in the city limits - but not many people know it's also the only capital city to offer a traditional mountain skiing experience in the city limits.
Finissage for Outsider in a Box by Dwora Fried
It’s hard to believe that Dwora Fried — a native Austrian with unruly, fiery red hair, a lesbian, world traveler, mother of four and daughter of a Holocaust survivor — is able to create artwork just as complicated, dynamic and vivacious as herself, all within a wooden box that’s only 31 centimeters wide, 21 centimeters high and 8 centimeters deep.
Austrian business to visit Iran
Austrian businesses are eyeing up commercial prospects in Iran amid expectations that trade sanctions against the country imposed by the United States and the European Union will be relaxed.
Semmering Zauberberg Opens This Weekend
The long awaited ski start at Vienna’s local ski resort Semmering Zauberberg kicks off this weekend when the pistes are opened for snow sports fans.
Meeting over oil production level held in Vienna
In a meeting behind closed doors in Austria this week, the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC) decided to maintain their target for oil barrel production at 30 million a day.
The most popular stories –
last 7 days
|Austria sees biggest increase in property prices in Europe|
|Two Brothels Closed in Red Light Clampdown|
|Austria has Top Four Ski Resorts|
|Unemployment rises by 10.8 per cent in comparison to November 2012|
|Campaign to Save Salzburg Airport Steps Up|
Why suffer in silence. Let off steam by letting our readers share your troubles. File your complaints about anything and everything here.
Our ombudsman David Rogers will try and help solve some of the problems from lazy civil servants through to incompetent companies – and at the very least the worst transgressors will end up in our weekly special report.