Tuesday, 11. March 2014
16. 12. 13. - 15:00
The capacity to think about how the present would be if an event in the past had taken a different course is referred to by experts as counter-factual reasoning.
A research project funded by the Austrian Science Fund FWF plans to examine how this kind of thinking develops, and identifies what distinguishes counter-factual reasoning from other types of conditional reasoning.
Moreover, it will investigate developmental links between counter-factual reasoning and emotions like regret and remorse, and whether counter-factual reasoning plays a central role in the development of scientific reasoning.
Thinking about what could have happened under different circumstances is part of people's everyday lives. This does, however, not apply to children. They seem to acquire this skill later in their cognitive development. The main question of the research project - funded by the FWF - is what children actually need to understand in order to be able to think counter-factually.
In adults, the process of considering alternatives generally follows this pattern: "We take a real event, for example a car accident, and incorporate an assumption that does not correspond to the facts (hence the assumption is counter to facts). We might then imagine what would have happened had we, for example, not speeded. We then change all of the facts in the chain of events to stay logically and causally coherent with the counter-factual assumption; for example, we then would not have skidded", explains the project leader Dr. Eva Rafetseder from the Department of Cognition and Development at the University of Salzburg.
The idea of such a minimally altered parallel world, in which a single aspect could have resulted in a different outcome to an actual event, is something that children only begin to understand from around 6 years on.
In the first part of the project, the scientists plan to carry out a series of studies involving a total of 280 children.
The aim is to clarify how young children interpret and understand counterfactual questions, for example: "If Susie had taken off her shoes would the floor be dirty or clean?" Tests with reference groups of English-speaking children should enable the researchers to identify language-related and educational features of this reasoning.
However, the project will extend far beyond merely clarifying the onset of this kind of reasoning. In a second phase, scientists intend to examine the emergence of emotions that accompany counter-factual reasoning.
"It is generally assumed that counter-factual reasoning triggers emotions like regret and remorse. We can think about how much better our lives would be now if we had taken the right decision at a certain point in the past. And we can regret this decision. Previous studies indicate that regret and remorse develop at a very early age: before the capacity for counter-factual reasoning. We would like to examine this contradiction in more detail", says Dr. Rafetseder.
Hence, the second part of the project, which will involve a total of 400 children, will examine the relationship between counter-factual reasoning and counter-factual emotions. It is believed that, from a very early age, children regret it if consequences are negative for them, for example, if they receive less than another child. Counter-factual reasoning, however, so the scientists, is not required for this. They suspect that the ability to regret one's own decisions ("if only I had done it differently") arises later, from around the age of 6 years, as counter-factual reasoning is assumed to provide the basis for this ability. Electro-physiological measurements will help the researchers to map the experience of counter-factual emotions, specifically in young children, who are often vague when it comes to expressing such feelings verbally.
The third part of the project is devoted to examining the way in which counter-factual reasoning is linked with scientific reasoning abilities: "Scientific enquiry involves establishing links between causes and effects. As with the formation of the minimally altered world in counter-factual reasoning, it is also necessary to make an assumption here ('if x is the cause') and to draw logically and causally compatible conclusions ('then we would observe y')", explains Dr. Rafetseder.
Over a total of 260 hours of pure testing time, 780 test subjects will be examined for their capacities for counter-factual reasoning and counter-factual emotions. The proposed ten studies that make up this FWF project will thereby provide insights into the way in which this key human skill develops.
Amy Winehouse exhibition in Vienna
Personal items belonging to late musician Amy Winehouse will be going on show in Vienna this week, as part of an exhibition designed in collaboration with her brother Alex Winehouse.
Task force recommends wind-down vehicle for Hypo
The task force assigned to find the best way to deal with ailing bank Hypo Alpe Adria has recommended that the government initiate a wind-down vehicle rather than creating the state "bad bank" preferred by Finance Minister Michael Spindelegger (OeVP).
American youth orchestras play free concerts in Austria
A free concert from an American youth orchestra is taking place in the Mozarteum in Salzburg this Friday 28 March.
Formal negotiations on Telekom Austria yet to begin
The state holding company that owns shares in Telekom Austria has said that negotiations over the pooling of its shares with telecoms company America Movil have not entered formal stages.
Victorias Secret could open soon in Vienna
A job posting on the website of the Vienna International Airport in Schwechat has fuelled rumours that Austria might be getting it's very first Victoria's Secret store.
Fashion students graduate with style
Last Saturday the fashion students from Vienna’s A-College held a fashion show for their graduating class at the MGC Modecenter.
English graffiti artists arrested in Austria
Austrian police say they have caught an internationally active graffiti artist from the UK together with three pals who now face up to 5 years in jail and a bill for thousands for the clean up work.
Irish banker in Austria with two wives
An Irish banker who worked for the World Bank in Vienna is being investigated by Austrian police after he was found to have two wives and children with both when he died suddenly, apparently of a natural death.
'Carnival of Languages' in Vienna
A "Carnival of Languages" is being put on in Vienna in March to celebrate the third birthday of the language centre Eton Institute in the city.
Police stop people carrier with 42 Romanians inside
Austrian police who stopped a people carrier licensed for nine people found it carrying a total of 42 people from Romania.
The most popular stories –
last 7 days
|Vienna first city to be granted personal domain name|
|Animal rights group protest against Burberry fur in Vienna|
|Irish banker in Austria with two wives|
|Another F1 Driver Hospitalised by Ski Accident|
|Austrian Relieved To Only be Dead On Paper|
Why suffer in silence. Let off steam by letting our readers share your troubles. File your complaints about anything and everything here.
Our ombudsman David Rogers will try and help solve some of the problems from lazy civil servants through to incompetent companies – and at the very least the worst transgressors will end up in our weekly special report.